I knew exactly what I wanted to replace it with...except that I didn't want to spend $70 on a copper mail box plus the cost of the post. So, I decided to buy a basic white one that looked like this for $17 instead:
And spray paint it with copper paint. I'm pretty excited about how it turned out!
Side one (with our picket fence in the background! More photos of that coming soon!):
Side two. Sorry for the sun ; ) :
There you have it. Not quite perfect, but I'm loving the charm! (And the $40+ that I saved.)
I will inevitably be asked what kind of spray paint I used. It was from Lowe's. It cost $7. And it was copper. = )

